Home |  English version |  Mappa |  Commenti |  Sondaggio |  Staff |  Contattaci Cerca nel sito  
Istituto di scienze e tecnologie della cognizione

Torna all'elenco Contributi in rivista anno 2014

Contributo in rivista

Tipo: Articolo in rivista

Titolo: Trust, relevance, and arguments

Anno di pubblicazione: 2014

Formato: Elettronico Cartaceo

Autori: Paglieri, Fabio; Castelfranchi, Cristiano

Affiliazioni autori: CNR-ISTC

Autori CNR:

  • CRISTIANO CASTELFRANCHI
  • FABIO PAGLIERI

Lingua: inglese

Abstract: This paper outlines an integrated approach to trust and relevance with respect to arguments: in particular, it is suggested that trust in relevance has a central role in argumentation. We first distinguish two types of argumentative relevance: internal relevance, i.e. the extent to which a premise has a bearing on its purported conclusion, and external relevance, i.e. a measure of how much a whole argument is pertinent to the matter under discussion, in the broader dialogical context where it is proposed. Then, we argue that judgements of internal relevance heavily rely on trust, and that such trust, although occasionally misplaced (e.g. in some so-called fallacies of relevance), is nonetheless based on several reasons, and thus often justified, by either epistemic or pragmatic considerations. We conclude by sketching potential methods to formally model trust in argumentative relevance, and briefly discussing the technological implications of this line of research. © 2014 Taylor & Francis.

Lingua abstract: inglese

Pagine da: 216

Pagine a: 236

Pagine totali: 21

Rivista:

Argument & computation Taylor & Francis
Paese di pubblicazione: Regno Unito
Lingua: inglese
ISSN: 1946-2166

Numero volume: 5

Numero fascicolo: 2-3

DOI: 10.1080/19462166.2014.899270

Referee: Sì: Internazionale

Indicizzato da: Scopus [2-s2.0-84900508986]

Parole chiave:

  • computational models of natural language argument
  • formal model of argumentation
  • relevance
  • trust

URL: http://www.scopus.com/record/display.url?eid=2-s2.0-84900508986&origin=inward

Strutture CNR:

Moduli:

 
Torna indietro Richiedi modifiche Invia per email Stampa
Home Il CNR  |  I servizi News |   Eventi | Istituti |  Focus